Return to CreateDebate.comhswanson1 • Join this debate community

Swanson JRG Grade 7


19emidtvedt's Waterfall RSS

This personal waterfall shows you all of 19emidtvedt's arguments, looking across every debate.
5 points

Palestinians have always been on that land alongside the Israelis. The Palestinians never left all at once like the Jews, who just abandoned there country. Instead they left in small groups so that there was always someone there.

When the U.N gave the Jews the land, The Palestinians left the country to avoid war, thinking that they could come back home, but they couldn't because the Israelis wouldn't allow them back in. I agree that the Jews were treated horribly during the holocaust, but that doesn't mean that they have to right to kick others out of there own homeland. The Palestinians were forced into refugee camps in other countries, because they had no place to go.

1 point

It doesn't give them the right to take away someone's homeland. They could have just shared, anyways the Palestinians WERE there first...

2 points

Yes, I agree that they were treated horribly during the holocaust, but you would think they would learn there lesson and share the land with the Palestinians, not break out into a war.

2 points

Yes, but that doesn't matter. You should be able to connect with everybody, not just the people in your religion.

1 point

Yes, the Palestinians were almost always there alongside the Jews, it's there homeland too.

2 points

Yes, but, the Jewish people left altogether, leaving the Palestinians there for a long time.

8 points

Yeah, but what about the Palestinians? Can't they both just share the land?

3 points

But Palestinians were there first, you can't just kick someone out of there homeland.

7 points

Palestinians should get at least half of Israel because, Palestinians have always been on that land and now they have no homeland. They left in small groups, but there has always been some of them there, unlike Israelis who left all at once. The Israelis forced them to leave there homes and go into refugee camps in neighboring countries. At first Palestinians left fled to other countries trying to avoid war, thinking they could come home, but they couldn't. The Israelis had already taken the land.



Results Per Page: [12] [24] [48] [96]